The Right is whining and wildly swinging over imaginary left wing activities in NY-23 (ACORN, anyone? The damn district is over 90% white). Could be a case of ‘protest too much’?
This is coming down to the wire and as an upstate New Yorker, I’d like to remind readers of a few things that just might swing things out of Hoffman’s favor:
Not to draw too fine a line on it, but New York’s North Country is our own little version of Alaska – the economy for the longest time depended on natural resources and pork. Now, all we’ve got is tourism..and pork.
People in the North Country may be conservative, but they also are very independent-minded and I’m going to make a bet that there is a lot of resentment about a) an outsider being put up, b) huge outside money being thrown, c) "their" Republican nominee being hung out to dry and publicly humiliated by Rush Limbaugh et al.
When you live in a place where 7 feet of snow falling in a god-damn week is a fairly regular occurrence, where you have to depend on your neighbors to plow you out and dig out your second floor windows, and anyone caught with engine trouble in the middle of the night between December and March could freeze to death if they tried to walk home alone…when the major economic engine of the place is either power (up in Gouverneur) or the military (Fort Drum), to have someone as ignorant as Hoffman being inserted into the community conversation sort of..sticks in your craw.
When you live in a place where sheer survival depends on everyone getting along and no one giving anyone a poke in the snoot, hearing that the election people have to call in the police because the Tea baggers are electioneering (which would be interpreted locally as harassment and intimidation, frankly) too close to the polling places – that’s not going to make you feel friendly toward a guy who doesn’t live in the district and whose monetary support came from not only outside the district…but WAY outside the district.
People may not have agreed with every position that Dede Scozzafava took – but she was a fairly popular State representative. She was ‘their own.’ To read that Rush Limbaugh referred to her as being involved in what would be considered even up there in the North Woods as ‘unnatural acts’ (even under blizzard conditions) would be too much for a lot of people to swallow. And of course, we won’t discuss the fact that John “Tanning Salon’ Boehner threw her under the bus today, saying that he resented even supporting her.
So, let’s see how ol’ Doug Hoffman does tonight. If he loses, a large part of it will be a message to the Right that poking their national noses into local politics might not be all that great a thing.






12 Comments
Spotlight
Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About The Seminal
Advanced search
Thank you, Toby. Rec’d.
Very helpful – thanks Toby!
Thanks, Aunt Toby. Rec’d.
You know what this and any election means. The people voted, picked a candidate and the one with the most votes wins.
Each individual voter made a decision, and like most of those decisions they may have not been in their best interests, but it was their decision.
No matter the outcome trying to make it into a trend is a bit much.
Looks like you nailed it, Toby. I’m seeing some reports now that the race is being called for Owens.
BUT this -Hoffman 46%- has got to make one wonder about NY-23 voters.
Good post. Reminds me of something said by a manager type at a firm I worked in, about a rather shabby client; ‘Well, she may be a b***h but she’s our b***h.
It has been called for Owens — which is great news for those of us longing to drave a stake through the Palin vampire’s heart.
Here’s the best analysis i’ve found of what really happened in maine:
http://airamerica.com/politics/11-04-2009/defeat-in-maine-a-harsh-blow-to-gay-marriage-drive/
Great job at calling it Toby!
Pull quote of the day:
Keep up that coalition building, especially the kind that divides your base and ends up with two smaller, warring factions!
Saa-weet!
Thanks Toby. So very nice to hear the local take on this. I was praying that the voters would be chafing at being told what to do by sleazebag outsiders. I was really pulling for the locals to get their voice heard over the GOP machinery yesterday. What a concept – voting in a democracy!
Good job NY 23.