Today’s (December 29) Washington Post has an article that Senator James Webb is going to take on prison reform.
This spring, Webb (D-Va.) plans to introduce legislation on a long-standing passion of his: reforming the U.S. prison system. Jails teem with young black men who later struggle to rejoin society, he says. Drug addicts and the mentally ill take up cells that would be better used for violent criminals. And politicians have failed to address this costly problem for fear of being labeled "soft on crime."
It is a gamble for Webb, a fiery and cerebral Democrat from a staunchly law-and-order state. Virginia abolished parole in 1995, and it trails only Texas in the number of people it has executed. Moreover, as the country struggles with two wars overseas and an ailing economy, overflowing prisons are the last thing on many lawmakers’ minds.
And of course, all the usual suspects start lining up against the idea.
State Sen. Ken Cuccinelli II (R-Fairfax), who is running for attorney general, said the initiative sounds "out of line" with the desires of people in Virginia but not necessarily surprising for Webb. The senator, he said, "is more emotion than brain in terms of what leads his agenda."
Gee, whoever would have guessed that a Republican state senator running for the state Attorney General position would think it’s a bad idea?
But there are other forces at play as well. The Prison Industrial Complex of course. With all the private prisons built over the last few years. But not just the private prisons, since many states have overbuilt prisons and rented out capacity.
But the article points out some of Webb’s reasoning:
In speeches and in a book that devotes a chapter to prison issues, Webb describes a U.S. prison system that is deeply flawed in how it targets, punishes and releases those identified as criminals.
With 2.3 million people behind bars, the United States has imprisoned a higher percentage of its population than any other nation, according to the Pew Center on the States and other groups. Although the United States has only 5 percent of the world’s population, it has 25 percent of its prison population, Webb says.
A disproportionate number of those who are incarcerated are black, Webb notes. African Americans make up 13 percent of the population, but they comprise more than half of all prison inmates, compared with one-third two decades ago. Today, Webb says, a black man without a high school diploma has a 60 percent chance of going to prison.
Webb aims much of his criticism at enforcement efforts that he says too often target low-level drug offenders and parole violators, rather than those who perpetrate violence, such as gang members. He also blames policies that strip felons of citizenship rights and can hinder their chances of finding a job after release. He says he believes society can be made safer while making the system more humane and cost-effective.
But the task is being made more difficult even as we speak. Just this weekend the AP had an article on how states are cutting back on Juvenile Justice programs due to the economic downturn.
Today’s Boston Globe had a report on a study on homicides among black males:
A study analyzing homicides across the country shows that Boston is among six major cities that have seen the sharpest spikes in the number of young black males killing one another between 2000 and 2007, an alarming trend that comes at a time when the state is cutting back on programs geared toward helping troubled youths.
Another story in today’s Post is how Child Neglect and Abuse cases are increasing due to the current economic stresses.
I don’t have any of the studies ready to hand but I know there have been many studies that show how victims of abuse and neglect, wind up more likely to be incarcerated.
So we have Senator Webb wanting to bring about prison reform. We have the "Lock ‘em up and throw away the key" types lining up against him. The Prison Industrial Complex will most likely be working behind the scenes.
We have Juvenile Justice Programs being cut due to lack of funds, leaving juveniles to be incarcerated with no treatment programs but learning first hand lessons on how to be a criminal.
We have young black men either in prison or dead from homicide.
We have increases of abuse and neglect due to economic hardship.
Senator Webb is truly taking on a Herculean task. Let’s do what we can to help him treat other humans as humans. Not every person needs to be incarcerated for decades.





31 Comments
Spotlight
Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About The Seminal
Advanced search
Please Digg
i’m so happy Senator Webb is taking this on.
And another thing i’d like to see addressed – felons losing their vote. I was getting out the vote for Ned Lamont and, in my assigned neighborhood, no one could vote – they were all felons. An entire neighborhood! Keep targeting a neighborhood and disenfranchise everyone. An underapreciated dirty trick.
It seems like forever ago that the prison system dropped the rehabilitation part of the “Punishment and Rehabilitation” mission.
Rehab doesn’t work, they averred. It’s not our job, they had their chance, etc. etc.
You connect the dots for us, dakine. Our silly liberal sociology isn’t so silly, after all.
Yeah, those Sociology/Criminology courses I took way back when do come in handy occasionally.
But all these articles that I link to and/or quote from were published in the last day or so. All related. Even though I’m sure there will be those who claim otherwise.
There is far too much money being made from the current system, that is a core problem, it is a cash cow.Reform is going to be fought from every corner of the system as they try to keep their cash flowing.
Bastards.
That’s why I touch on the Prison Industrial complex and the fact that htis will be a Herculean task to implement.
Just as with attempts to reform and re-work the DoD and the MIC, the forces aligned against this are vast.
and reddit
Another data point: according to a presentation I attended by Larry Mishel of the Economic Policy Institute, we can expect to see 50% African American youth unemployment by the end of 2010 given the economic cliff dive.
Thanks dakine01,
Now the msrnc prison doc-blocs are making a little more sense to me. These programs seem to run on an endless loop every night and during the holiday break and on weekends on daytime.
This is why I change the channel after I watch Rachel Maddow.
msrnc- catapulting the fear
I was happy to see that prison reform is finally getting some attention. I think the first thing that needs to stop is private for-profit prisons….gotta have criminals to make money in that scheme. Bill Moyers did an excellent program on the subject of private prisons a few months ago. It was kind of shocking to learn that the people running those prisons are actually writing some of the crime bills. Then add “illegal” immigrants to the mix and the prison folks are writing those bills too. That needs to stop!
Busted, you have most accurately summed up the ‘drive’ behind the current, failed and destructive ’system’ as well as the fundamental ‘nature’ of those who promote it …
And bravo to Dakine for broaching this subject as well as special thanks to Senator Webb for having the courage to challenge the ‘comfortable notions’ surrounding the pathectic absurdity we are proud and pleased to call our ‘modern’ approach to penology.
DW
Add the DAs who go for the easily-winnable cases to make themselves look more effective, while more dangerous criminals tend to be acquitted or get hung juries because of poor work by the DA’s (generally overworked) minions or the (almost always overworked) crime labs.
And the judges, who are frequently former prosecutors because they’re the only ones who have publicly available work records at election time.
And the juries, who will frequently believe a witness because it’s a police officer and ‘they wouldn’t lie about it’, even when they do. Or assume someone is guilty because ‘they wouldn’t have been arrested if they hadn’t done something’.
(I’ve heard of prosecutors bullying people into pleading guilty when the first trial ends in a hung jury, by telling them that the DA will keep trying them until they’re convicted, at the same time knowing that they can’t afford the lawyer after the first trial ends. That’s another kind of crime.)
Dugg This is great now then is there any chance Obama will make this a priority 1 out of 10 African Americans go through the system.
Can it pass the Senate?
First lowering CEO pay and now this Webb has my vote for best crossover Republican heck he is more Left than the entire DLC!
I think he wants to be President!
Well, if we want Obama to do anything, we will most likely have to force the issue. Lining up support for Webb’s efforts sure seems to be a reasonable start.
There’s good money in prisons. The Indictment dust up in Texas re: Dick Cheney – investor – in a private prison corporation – and as a government official – instrumental in raising the per diem rate per inmate – paid by government – to the prisons.
Privatization is a scheme to reward political contributors – with sweetheart deals – and rob the public.
Dugg. Thanks for the post.
But who better to write rules than the people who have to live with them… (Bushreasoning)
NOW (PBS show) has an excellent series (I’m not sure that the link worked, but it’s http://www.pbs.org/now/shows/419/idex.html)
Then, read about UNICOR (www.unicor.gov), “a self-sustaining, self-funded corporation established in 1934 by executive order to create a voluntary real-world work program to train federal inmates.” Sounds good. But the prisoners make everything from furniture to clothing to electronics to providing help desk services and much much more. In UNICOR’s words “Imagine… All the benefits of domestic outsourcing at offshore prices. It’s the best kept secret in outsourcing!” So, we continue on our long history of slave labor. It’s going to be difficult to bring this system down as the prison industry is a major funder of our senators and congressmen, and they help write the laws to insure there’s a continuing source of labor.
sorry ffein my comment meant to ref. yours at 10
Minority teenagers are six to nine times as likely to be incarcerated than a white kid convicted of the same offence.
I really don’t see that anyone can argue with any sincerity that there isn’t something terribly wrong, and racist, with the way the system works.
Sorry. Link.
That is why a coalition of organization to support prison reform as well as semtecing guidelines is critical to get traction.
The Webb Coalition for Justice
Minority teens are poorer than Bush family hoodlums. Consequently, they end up with a Public Defender instead of a private attorney.
DW Bartoo
DW I agree. Senator Webb must like big challenges.
From what little I’ve paid attention to it, the American criminal justice system is about retribution, punishment, and scapegoating which is violent at its core. I understand a large percentage of people behind bars are non-violent drug offenders which reflects the government’s phobia about altering consciousness. Seems to me we need to deal with abuse of drugs as a mental health issue not a criminal justice issue. As for violent criminals, of course they need to be separated from the general population, but a culture that perpetuates violence and destroys the self worth of individuals is self-defeating and destructive to the collective as well.
The senator, he said, “is more emotion than brain in terms of what leads his agenda.”
This always cracks me up. As if the driven-by-fear-and-hatred authoritarian crowd are the ones thinking with their “brains” and the liberals who know that preventative measures combined with criminal justice reform will save us millions and millions of dollars (or more) over the long run, while making society more productive and reducing crime are the ones driven by “emotion.”
Also, something to watch out for are – and I don’t say this lightly – the prison guard unions. The California Correctional Peace Officers Association (CCPOA), for example, is extremely powerful and holds a lot of lobbying sway (e.g., with regard to legislation for harsher sentences, including “three strikes.” Harsher sentences = job security). It’s not just the private prisons we need to worry about.
legaleagle;
Your second paragraph is too true, and deserves very serious considerations … a similar ‘reality’ attends unions which seek ‘defense’ related contracts without regard to how and on whom their handiwork might be lavished.
DW
I’m late to this thread, but I do want to add that this is very good news, and is a task very suited to Webb’s strengths, including his pitbull-ishness.
Be interesting to see what can be done against some pretty overwhelming odds.
Kathryn, you’re dead-on re: disenfranchisement. A political incentive opposed to the resolution of underlying problems.
Brings to mind the issue of different penalties (and conviction standards) relating to cocaine and crack. Cocaine fashionable on wall st – crack the drug of “the” streets.
Largely state issues. 50 state strategy anyone..
“50 state strategy …”
Sounds like a plan, Sunny.
Let’s do it~!!!
Barack are you listening?
In California it’s pretty clear that the Prison System (which costs as much as the entire higher educational system) is a major cause of the fact the State teeters on bankruptcy right now. Many of those in jail are there because of silly “three strikes” convictions, usually drug related…and due to treatable addictions. It’s been pointed out that the Prison Guards Union also handles the Probation Officers, so the crackdown on people on probation (and these violations are far easier to convict on) keeps the prisons full to the brim. That maintains the demand for guards…and more probation officers.
Heck…we even supply private prisons in other States!
Nowhere, but California
http://www.nathancallahan.com/threestrikes.html