Why I Fight Against Torture: Part Two
A few days ago, I shared with the Firedoglake community the story of my husband, Dan who was a Vietnam vet who survived torture.
Today I will share the story of one of the former Guantanamo Bay detainees.
Murat Kurnaz
Mr. Kurnaz was born in Bremen, Germany, had always lived in Germany, and was of Turkish descent. In Germany, those of Turkish descent having a much more difficult time becoming German citizens even those born in Germany. In 2001, he decided to learn more about his religion, Islam, in preparation for his Turkish wife joining him, so he traveled to Pakistan to learn from peaceful Imams. Enroute back to Germany, on December 1, 2001, he was taken off a bus in Pakistan, and taken to a prison in Peshawar, Pakistan, then to Kandahar, Afghanistan, and, finally to Guantanamo Bay, where he remained until August 4th, 2006.
What I share now are excerpts from his book "Five Years of My Life: An Innocent Man in Guantanamo." These are the things that have been done to fellow human beings.
Today I will share some of his experiences in Kandahar, tomorrow the rest of his journey.
In Kandahar:
Did they have a lie detector? I asked myself. The man was holding something in his hands. It looked like two irons that he was rubbing together. Or one of those machines used to revive people who have heart attacks. Before I realized what was happening, I felt the first jolt.
It was electricity. An electric shock. They put the electrodes to the soles of my feet. There was no way to remain seated. It was as though my body was lifting itself off the ground of its own accord. I felt the electric current going through my whole body. There was a bang. It hurt a lot. I felt warmth, jolts, cramps. My muscles cramped up and quivered. That hurt, too.
… I heard screams.
They were my screams
On the table, there was a shallow, blue plastic bucket about 20 inches in diameter, full of water.
…
I knew what was coming.
They pushed my head into the plastic tub.
It’s like bobbing for apples, I thought.
…
I wasn’t afraid, but I was very nervous. I didn’t know whether I was going to survive.
…
Someone grabbed me by the hair. The soldiers seized my arms and pushed my head underwater.
…
They pulled my head back up.
"Do you like it?"
"You want more?"
"You’ll get more, no problem."
When my head was back underwater, I felt a blow to my stomach. I had to exhale and cough. I wanted to breathe back in but forced my self not to, and I supressed the urge to cough. Still, I inhaled a bit of water and could hardly hold my breath.
"Where is Osama?"
"Who are you?"
I tried to speak but I couldn’t.
"More!"
I felt blows to my stomach and against my back. I swallowed some water. It was a strange feeling. I don’t know whether the water went to my lungs. It became harder and harder to breathe, the more they hit me in the stomach and pushed my head underwater. I felt my heart racing. They didn’t let up. I tried to answer their questions when I managed to get a fresh breath of air, but all I could manage was "yes" and "no." I was choking. I felt like I was going to vomit, then I coughed and spat. I was dizzy and nauseous.
When they pushed my head under water again and me in the stomach, I imagined myself screaming underwater.
Habe allahu we ne emel weki!
I would have told them everything. But what was I supposed to tell them?
It wasn’t a room, just a pen enclosed by aluminum and chain-link fence. Hanging from a beam was a hook like the ones used in butcher shops. A chain dangled from the ceiling.
The soldiers took the chain and ran it underneath my handcuffs. They looped the chain over the hook like a block and tackle and fed it into a winch. I was hoisted up until my feet no longer touched the ground. They clamped the chain to the beam and then left without a word, shutting the corrugated door behind them.
The cuffs cut off the blood to my hands. I tried to move.
…
I knew they were going to leave my hanging there until I couldn’t take it any more. After a while, the cuffs seemed like they were cutting my wrists down to the bone. My shoulders felt like someone was trying to pull my arms out of their sockets.
At some point, I began rocking myself back and forth in the hope that would get my blood flowing. But every movement hurt, no matter how tiny. Especially in my wrists and elbow. The best thing was just not to move and resign yourself to the pain.
At some point, hours later. someone came and let me down. A doctor examined me and took my pulse. He was wearing a uniform like the other soldiers, but he had a badge of rank on his shoulders, and a patch on his chest said: "Doctor."
"Okay,: he said.
The soldiers hoisted me back up.
Three times a day. the soldiers came with the doctor and lowered me.
…
My hands had swollen. In the beginning, I’d felt pain in them. Later on, I lost all feeling in my arms and hands. I still felt pain in other parts of my body, like in my chest around my heart.
When they hung me up backwards, it felt as though my shoulders were going to break. They bound my hands behind my back and hoisted me up. I could remember seeing something like that in a movie once – only in the film, it was Americans being strung up by the Vietnamese with their hands behind their backs until they died.
…
I didn’t recognize the man. He was hanging as I was from the ceiling. I couldn’t tell whether he was dead or alive. His body was mostly swollen and blue, although in some places it was pale and white. I could see a lot of blood in his face, dark streams of it. His head lolled to one side. I couldn’t see his eyes.
…
No one came to lower the man next to me. They had forgotten him. He just hung there in the same position. I thought about the prisoner with the blanket wrapped around his head. They didn’t seem to care whether we died.
…
I watch his chest for a while. Nothing moved.
…
I was strung up for about five days.
These are some of the things that were done in your name. I will continue Murat Kurnaz’s story tomorrow
It is extremely important that those responsible, from the highest to the lowest are held accountable, legally accountable.
Torture is not what Dan fought for. It is not what Dan gave his physical health for. It is not what Dan gave his mental health for.
Please, I need YOUR help. We need to stand up and show those in power in Washington that we will settle for nothing less than independent investigations and prosecutions. We MUST take that responsibility.
We must March for Accountability.
I am just at the beginning of bringing together the people and organizations necessary to organize a March for Accountability. If you would like to help, or want to keep updated, please email me at the address in my profile.
With gratitude and respect,
Hugs,
Standing for Justice and Accountability,
For Dan,
Heather





15 Comments
Spotlight
Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About The Seminal
Advanced search
makes me nauseous just reading this. dayam.
recommended heather.
Recommended
((Heather))
Heather you are so right, I did not serve either for torture to be committed by Americans in my name. I am ashamed of my country and Justice must be meted out to any and all who anything to do with this.
Thank you for your work Heather.
” By Kate Allen, Amnesty International Uk Director
It’s taken three months to resolve the situation of one detainee out of 240. At this rate, it will take another 65 years to clear the camp.
Meanwhile, despite signs of a new willingness to tackle at least some of the poisonous legacy of arbitrary detention, torture memos and abuse, the Obama government has blocked all attempts by former victims of illegal detention who’ve sought to bring to book a Boeing subsidiary company for illegally flying them between prisons as part of the CIA’s shadowy ‘extraordinary rendition’ programme.
And it doesn’t end there. Earlier this month, White House lawyers sought to stop more than 500 prisoners held at a US-run prison at Bagram in Afghanistan from being able to challenge their indefinite detention – an incarceration totally devoid of either charges or trials.
Bagram, nicknamed the Afghan Guantanamo, has a fearsome reputation, with conditions reported to be far worse than those at the Cuban site. Several inmates have died in custody, apparently after sustained torture.
So how does all this square with the stirring sentiments in Obama’s inauguration speech in January?
‘We reject as false the choice between our safety and our ideals,’ he said. But isn’t it precisely this false choice that’s still being made in the name of providing ’security’? “
http://www.cageprisoners.com/articles.php?id=28805
” The lawyer who exposed those behind America’s interrogation techniques believes a criminal investigation is now essential
Philippe Sands
The world is watching as America attempts to come to terms with the abuse it unleashed in the aftermath of 9/11 and trying to digest the full implications of last week’s extraordinary events. With a wide-ranging Spanish criminal investigation into torture at Guantánamo threatening to embarrass the US, Barack Obama decided to declassify legal memos sent under the Bush administration in the hope the country would move on. The opposite has happened. Ever more documents set out in meticulous detail the full extent of the cruelty: who was abused by whom, how they did it and what was done. The truth has been revealed in stark detail, from the number of times waterboarding was used to the legal deliberations that led to it. By Tuesday, President Obama had raised the possibility of US war crimes trials and far-reaching inquiries, developments that were unthinkable a month ago.
Torture has deeply damaged the reputation of the US, a country that has done more than any other to promote the idea of the international rule of law. Such harm cannot be repaired merely by putting out the documents. Accountability is needed. An investigation is inevitable, but what kind should it be? In theory, a criminal investigation and an independent or congressional inquiry are not mutually exclusive. In reality, it is difficult for them to go hand in hand. Criminal proceedings will halt the flow of information, as those who fear prosecution clam up.
Yet serious crimes have been committed and, as a nation of laws, the US is bound to investigate criminal wrongdoing. This is a difficult balance to strike. The way forward may be to begin with the fullest possible investigation by a blue chip independent commission, with the power to compel the production of documents and witness testimony. This will only be a temporary reprieve of the inevitable criminal inquiry, however, whether in the US, Spain or elsewhere, and long overdue disbarment proceedings for the lawyers. “
http://www.cageprisoners.com/articles.php?id=28806
In torturing Khalid Sheik Mohammed and his fellows we have created a class of permanent martyrs, unjustly imprisoned in the eyes of the world because they cannot be legitimately tried and punished. We have let torture destroy justice.
Mark Danner“The Paradoxes of the Torture Scandal”
The stories of all of the tortured are at this site. Chacounne..the first time that I read your article about your beloved husband, it crossed my mind that you were tortured, too. You are not just doing this for Dan; you are doing this for every detainee’s family member who will go through exactly what you did with Dan. The detainees someday will be free physically, they will never be free mentally.I’d like to see some of these detainee’s stories read to Congress. Get it on record just like the Pentagon Papers. Send the links to any group that is demanding accountability. The author is offering the information for free; what a wonderful gift to the world. Thank you for posting Kurnaz’s story. Torture is just a word until people know what happened to the person’s mind, body, and spirit.
*************************
” The following list (also see Part 2, Part 3 and Part 4) is the culmination of a three-year project to record the stories of all the prisoners held at the US prison in Guantánamo Bay, Cuba. The first fruit of this research was my book The Guantánamo Files: The Stories of the 774 Detainees in America’s Illegal Prison, published by Pluto Press in November 2007, and available from Amazon (US and UK), in which I related the story of Guantánamo, established a chronology explaining where and when the prisoners were seized, told the stories of around 450 of these prisoners, and provided a context for the circumstances in which the remainder of the prisoners were captured.
” In the last 15 months, I have also published 12 online chapters telling the stories of over 250 prisoners that I was unable to include in the book (either because they were not available at the time of writing, or to keep the book at a manageable length), and have written over 300 articles about Guantánamo, for a variety of publications, expanding on and updating the stories of all 779 prisoners. In particular, I have covered the stories of the 143 prisoners released from Guantánamo since June 2007 in unprecedented depth, and have also covered the stories of the 27 prisoners charged in Guantánamo’s Military Commission trial system in more detail than is available from most, if not all other sources.
“It is my hope that this project will provide an invaluable research tool for those seeking to understand how it came to pass that the government of the United States turned its back on domestic and international law, establishing torture as official US policy, and holding men without charge or trial neither as prisoners of war, protected by the Geneva Conventions, nor as criminal suspects to be put forward for trial in a federal court, but as ‘illegal enemy combatants.’
“I also hope that it provides a compelling explanation of how that same government, under the leadership of George W. Bush, Dick Cheney and Donald Rumsfeld, established a prison in which the overwhelming majority of those held — at least 93 percent of the 779 men and boys imprisoned in total — were either completely innocent people, seized as a result of dubious intelligence or sold for bounty payments, or Taliban foot soldiers, recruited to fight an inter-Muslim civil war that began long before the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001, and that had nothing to do with al-Qaeda, Osama bin Laden or international terrorism.” “
http://www.andyworthington.co……oner-list/
Thanks, Heather. So many innocent people were abducted and tortured in our names. It will take a very long time before our country is seen in a good light again with respect to human rights.
Please consider keeping us posted in diaries as your plans for a march come along.
Thank you, Heather (and your Dan). Thanks also to all who comment here and add as we can to the growing pressure to cease this sadistic, beastly, subhuman practice of torturing any person or living creature.
I’ve come to think of us as “Dan’s Brigade”.
Jim, I’m asking again for one of your fine articles. As I read the copyright rules at the article to which I refer here, any presentation of the article’s content would have to be strictly a critique. Jim, you have the tools and skills required; I do not. Please.
link first supplied by bluebutterfly. Thanks, blue.
Thank you Heather.
Thank you for personalizing the burden we all carry, the shame we all collectively share and for identifying the reason we must cleanse the spirit of the America we love.
((((((((((((((((((acquarius)))))))))))))))))))))))))
Oh my goodness ! How sweet and wonderful !
I know Dan is smiling down and shaking his head, and asking:
“What did I do to deserve that?”
Thank you,
Hugs,
Heather
Heather, you should not be surprised. It has been quite a sight, watching you assert yourself, becoming a force.
Dan’s Brigade has a very nice ring.
(((((((((((((((((newtonusr)))))))))))))))))))
Thank you, my friend.
Tears falling,
Hugs,
For Dan,
Heather