Conservative cesspool National Review Online’s John J. Miller apparently has nothing important to write about. Yesterday he expressed grave concern (warning: NRO link) as to whether or not the upcoming G.I. Joe: The Rise of Cobra movie will be American enough. "I keep wondering: Is G.I. Joe still an American?" he ponders.
His evidence, which is based on his viewing of a couple trailers, leafing through the book and comic tie-ins at the store, and the movie’s website, is thus:
The old logo was red, white, and blue. Now the dominant image is black.
Now we all know that black is evil, but who knew that the U.S. Army isn’t American any more. Neither is the U.S. Air Force. If only they had more colorful logos.
Nobody wears green Army uniforms. Instead, the good guys appear to put on silver-plated robocop armor.
Wait, wasn’t Robocop a good American? A police officer that followed the law to the tee not a real American? Another childhood hero tarnished beyond repair. I guess this guy isn’t an American either, but he does look like an action figure at least.
Joe and his friends look like celluloid heroes without a country.
I’m not quite sure where he’s going with that statement. Maybe he is trying to equate the non-green, red, white and blue wearing characters to terrorists. Al Qaeda isn’t affiliated with any one country in particular. G.I. Joe characters don’t wear outfits that that seem to align them with any one country in particular. Therefor, G.I. Joe is a terrorist organization. Perfect neo-con logic.
Miller closes his screed with:
Perhaps Hollywood thinks a moratorium on American patriotism is necessary in order to attract an international audience. But it would be nice if the studios and producers thought they might play a role in the public diplomacy of creating goodwill abroad. G.I. Joe: The Rise of Cobra looks like a load of fun. It may also be another missed opportunity.
The Republicans are well known for their desire to create goodwill abroad (especially in Argentina). Secret torture prisons, indefinite detentions and extraordinary rendition are all evidence of that. Instead of asking if Hollywood will polish a turd, and cover up the truth with fake goodwill, why not just shift your foreign policy to reflect the goodwill you desire?
Mr. Miller, if you aren’t happy with the way your favorite childhood toy has evolved, why don’t you just stick to reruns of "24". Jack Bauer will always be a true patriot and a real American Hero.
…oh wait, never mind. Jack Bauer’s choice of attire and "24" logo may not fit your guidelines of chromatically acceptable, patriotic entertainment. Better stick with The Greatest American Hero.
Relax John, it’s just a movie.





13 Comments
Spotlight
Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About The Seminal
Advanced search
Love the uniform.
Here is a clip of Miller debating this on MSNBC.
He is kind of a douche. Donnie calls him ignorant.
http://progressnotcongress.org/?p=2331
scares me, but then we ARE the Empire
G.I. Joe was outsourced a long time ago. Where has Miller been?
I refuse to take John J. Miller’s opinion seriously until I’ve gazed upon his original birth certificate with my very own eyes. His wiki bio CLAIMS he was born in Detroit but that is right across the river from Windsor, Ontario, so he is NEARLY if not ACTUALLY Canadian. Either way, he has a lot of nerve pretending to speak for Americans…
He was born at Cobra headquarters in France
good point. demand to see the video of his birth!
This story gives me a rising cobra.
We can change America. All we have to do is sit behind a keyboard and type as fast as we can. Now that’s real change.
Don’t tell Miller, but there’s a military group just across the border that features prominently the word black. They must be really evil!
Err….that 2030 Proposed Uniform? No crotch armor! Is there some top secret stealth technology, mebbe?
In the first issue of GI Joe, the gloating, leering villainess was an absolute dead ringer for Gloria Steinem. *Sigh* Ms Steinem appeared at our mall to sign a book a month or two later. I was so tempted to ask her what she thought of “her” appearance there, but I restrained myself.
“Mr. Miller, if you aren’t happy with the way your favorite
childhoodtoy has evolved, why don’t you just stick to reruns of “24″. Jack Bauer will always be a true patriot and a real American Hero.”Nice job, twolf, but never assume, it makes an ass…., etc., etc..