I’ve reviewed the highly negative effects of premature political framing of issues in the bank bailout, economic stimulus, Afghanistan policy re-evaluation, and health insurance reform areas. But, we can also see the same thing going on in cap-and-trade, credit card reform, and the discussion just beginning on a possible jobs bill. The frames of this Administration begin by excluding politically infeasible solutions. We will probably see this again in the areas of education, energy, and the environment, and in any other problems the Administration tackles. And we will also see it back solutions that create similar dynamics in the Media, the blogosphere, the public, and the Congress. This pattern however, does not serve us well. It has a bias toward political expediency at the price of real practicality – getting to solutions that work. If we can’t disturb this pattern, if the Administration is allowed to “pre-compromise” on solutions by using the political feasibility frame, before it has used a “how well does this solution work relative to others” frame, we will continue to get bad results.
What we need to do to get out of this box, is to be truly pragmatic. All of us, including the Administration, need to consider all the ideas that may work to solve a problem, and compare and debate them without first considering their political feasibility. We need to suspend judgment about that while we evaluate a solution on its own merits. That’s because political feasibility can’t be pre-determined. It is not a pre-condition of the legislative process, to be divined intuitively by the experienced and self-annointed political gurus. It is an outcome of that process. It has to be determined by political conflict and negotiation, and also by how well proposed solutions perform in actual debate. In its focus on “the perfect is the enemy of the good,” the Obama Administration has forgotten that “the timid is the enemy of the good,” also. In issue after issue, it has embraced the timid, and the result is that its solutions to the nation’s problems don’t work.